Once kids learn hard work earns more, they start accepting extreme inequality

In a study of 81 children aged 4 to 8, younger kids judged lopsided cookie splits as less fair the more extreme they were, even when one child worked harder, while older kids approved even relatively extreme splits of 10 cookies once told one character did most of the work.

Share this:

Young children have a sharp sense of when a split is too lopsided. Somewhere around age six or seven, that sense can switch off: told that one person worked harder, older children were willing to accept almost any inequality, even one person getting everything.

The study is by Nadia Chernyak of the Department of Cognitive Sciences at the University of California, Irvine. It appeared in the February 2024 issue of the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology.

Ten cookies, two bakers

Eighty-one children aged 4 to 8 took part, almost all over Zoom, between December 2020 and January 2023. Each heard 12 short stories about two characters who baked 10 cookies together.

In six stories, both characters did half the work. In the other six, one “did a lot of the work” and the other “did a little bit”. The phrasing was deliberately vague, mirroring how merit is usually talked about. Each story ended with a different split, from 5-5 to 10-0, and children pointed to a happy or sad face to say whether it was OK.

The key question was numerical sensitivity. A fair-minded judge should see a 9-1 split as worse than a 6-4 split, at least when both people worked equally.

Older children stopped counting

When both characters worked the same, children of every age behaved as expected: the more uneven the split, the less likely they were to call it OK.

The merit stories split the groups. Younger children, below the median age of 6.44 years, were slightly more accepting of inequality when one character worked harder, but they still judged extreme splits as less fair than mild ones.

Older children were comfortable with most forms of inequality once they heard that one character did most of the work. Their judgments still varied with the size of the split, but far less steeply, so even near-total allocations to the harder worker were widely accepted.

The downside of learning meritocracy

Chernyak describes this as a double-edged sword. Children are learning a legitimate principle, that harder work deserves more, but they appear to acquire it before they learn to ask how much more is reasonable.

It is unusual in development, she notes, because children usually become more numerically precise with age. Here the younger children were the more precise judges of inequality in the merit case.

She speculates that failing to distinguish moderate from extreme merit-based inequality could be a building block of “just world” beliefs, the conviction that large inequalities are deserved. The study took place in the United States, which she describes as a high-inequality, capitalist setting where merit beliefs might be especially likely to override sensitivity to numbers. Comparing other cultures is one of the directions she proposes.

Study Details:

  • Title: The emergence of young children’s tolerance for inequality: With age, children stop showing numerically sensitive fairness
  • Authors: Nadia Chernyak
  • Journal: Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
  • Publication Date: February 2024
  • DOI: 10.1016/j.jecp.2023.105785