People who are open to being wrong seem better at understanding how others feel. Across three preregistered studies, higher intellectual humility went with greater empathic accuracy, the ability to correctly read another person’s emotional state.
The research was carried out by Michal Lehmann, Shir Genzer, Nur Kassem, Daryl R. Van Tongeren and Anat Perry, with authors at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Carnegie Mellon University and Hope College. It was published online in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin on February 4, 2025.
The team set out to test how intellectual humility relates to two kinds of empathy: cognitive empathy, or understanding what someone feels, and emotional empathy, or responding to it.
Three studies, 533 participants
Study 1, with 212 participants, found a positive link between intellectual humility and empathic accuracy. The link was especially strong when people judged the emotions of members of an outgroup.
Study 2, with 112 participants, replicated the association. Study 3, with 209 participants, tried to show cause and effect by using a manipulation designed to boost intellectual humility.
The manipulation raised participants’ momentary intellectual humility, which in turn was associated with greater empathic accuracy. The authors describe this as an indirect effect.
Empathy without burnout
A mini meta-analysis pooling the studies showed that, on average, people higher in intellectual humility understood others’ emotional states better.
The trait also predicted what the authors call empathic resilience. Humble participants were buffered against personal distress while maintaining or even increasing their empathic concern for others.
In other words, humble people cared as much or more for others without becoming more upset themselves. The authors argue the trait could help foster deeper connections and better understanding in social interactions.
Study Details:
- Title: Intellectual Humility Predicts Empathic Accuracy and Empathic Resilience
- Authors: Michal Lehmann, Shir Genzer, Nur Kassem, Daryl R. Van Tongeren, Anat Perry
- Journal: Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
- Publication Date: February 4, 2025
- DOI: 10.1177/01461672241313427
