Money from a returned purchase burns a hole in the pocket. Across 10 studies with 2,710 participants, people were more likely to make an unplanned purchase, and to pick an indulgent product, when spending a refund than when spending the same amount from their wallet or paycheck.
The reason, according to consumer researcher Ata Jami, is that refund money still feels like “spent money,” so spending it again hurts less. The paper was published online in the Journal of Behavioral Decision Making on January 28, 2025 (read the paper).
The stakes are large. Americans returned about 14.5% of their retail purchases in 2023, worth $743 billion, more than twice what they received in income tax refunds that year.
Real shopping data and shopping scenarios
The first study used real purchase and return histories that 179 participants downloaded from an online retailer, covering 11,375 purchases and 757 refunds over 102 days in early 2021. On an average day, the chance of making a purchase was about 20.6%. It rose to 24.6% within three days of receiving a refund and to 23% within seven days. Larger refunds also nudged up spending in the next three days, but that effect faded within a week.
The remaining studies were online experiments. In a typical one, people imagined buying pants and spotting an unplanned $55 shirt. Those told they had just returned $100 of items rated their likelihood of buying the shirt at 3.46 on a seven-point scale, compared with 2.71 for those told they had $100 in their wallet.
The effect held when the extra item was in a different store and a different product category. Offered a choice between a luxurious phone case and a drop-proof one, people spending refund money leaned more toward the luxurious design.
Less pain of paying, especially for tightwads
In a study of 453 people, spending refund money on $60 shoes felt more pleasurable and less painful than spending wallet money, and that difference in pain explained the higher willingness to buy. Tax refund money, by contrast, did not differ significantly from wallet money.
If pain of paying is the key, refunds should matter most to people who feel that pain most strongly. A two-part study measured participants’ “tightwad” or “spendthrift” tendencies six weeks before the shopping scenario. The refund effect appeared among the more tightwad half of participants and vanished among the more free-spending half.
Not just old money or found money
Two preregistered studies tested whether refunds simply feel less valuable because the original payment was long ago. Whether the item had been bought 5 or 45 days earlier made no significant difference. Even when the store had not yet charged the card, so the shopper merely cancelled a pending payment, people were still more willing to buy something extra.
A final study compared a $95 refund with $95 from a paycheck or a lottery win. Willingness to buy $80 shoes averaged 4.78 for refund money, 4.34 for lottery money and 2.99 for paycheck money. Refunds were spent at least as readily as a pure windfall, even though people rated them as less windfall-like.
All participants were American, and most studies used hypothetical scenarios. Jami suggests that shoppers on tight budgets treat refunds as income they already earned, and notes that the real-world data point to a simple tactic: wait a few days after a refund before buying anything new.
Study Details:
- Title: Generous Returners, Vanishing Refunds: How Consumers Spend Monetary Refunds of Returns
- Authors: Ata Jami
- Journal: Journal of Behavioral Decision Making
- Publication Date: January 28, 2025
- DOI: 10.1002/bdm.70009
