Lifetime pay gaps take shape in the first five years of work, study finds

What workers bring to their first job explains 26% of lifetime earnings inequality, but measured five years in, starting conditions appear to explain 46%. Much of the gap forms early, as more skilled workers increasingly land better-matched jobs.

Share this:

Much of the gap between high and low lifetime earners opens up in the first few years of work, not before it. What workers bring to their first job explains about 26% of lifetime earnings inequality, but measured five years later, the same starting conditions appear to explain 46%.

Paulo Lins of Clemson University and Xiaonan Ma make the case in a working paper posted on SSRN in July 2026. Their point is partly about method: studies that start the clock in a worker’s early twenties end up counting early-career luck and choices as if they were fixed traits.

Starting the clock at graduation, not at a birthday

Most research on lifetime inequality begins at a common age, often 23 or 25. The authors argue that for people who start work straight out of high school, that is already years into their careers.

In the long-running US survey they use, workers born between 1957 and 1964 had on average more than five years of work experience by age 25. By then they had changed jobs, been out of work, and drifted into better or worse positions.

So the researchers anchored everything to labor-market entry instead. They followed high-school graduates who never returned to education, 3,341 people from the 1979 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth and 1,563 from the 1997 survey, and fitted a monthly model of hours, skills, job changes and savings to their work histories.

Skills and good jobs find each other

Measured at entry, initial assets, skills, job quality and taste for work account for 26.4% of lifetime earnings inequality. Moving the starting line five years later raises that share to 45.6%, a jump of more than 19 percentage points that really reflects what happened during those first years.

The main driver of widening pay gaps in that window is sorting. At entry, workers with more skills are not especially likely to hold better-matched jobs. Five years in, they clearly are, because in the model skills make it easier to find work, lower the risk of losing a job, and bring better offers.

That changes why young workers put in hours. Building skills is the biggest reason to work more early on, yet only about half of that pull comes through future wages. The rest comes from steadier employment and better job prospects, a channel the authors say standard models leave out.

What the numbers can and cannot say

The sample covers only high-school graduates from specific cohorts, and the authors caution that their figures are not directly comparable with earlier estimates. An influential earlier study that started at age 23 found initial conditions explained roughly 60% of lifetime inequality, using different data and a different model.

Their conclusion is that the early career is not a short warm-up but a formative stretch, and that policies affecting hiring, job security and job search may shape lifetime outcomes more than wage-focused models suggest.

Study Details:

  • Title: The Early Career and the Sources of Lifetime Inequality
  • Authors: Paulo Lins, Xiaonan Ma
  • Journal: Clemson University Working Paper (SSRN)
  • Publication Date: July 2026
  • DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.7186878