Republican-donor CEOs are three times as likely to make liberal-leaning social statements

In S&P 500 firms, 97% of CEO statements on social issues leaned liberal and Republican-donor CEOs were three times as likely to make them; store visits rose 3% afterwards, driven by Democrat counties, with no significant drop in Republican ones.

Share this:

When a chief executive speaks out on gun control or racial justice, it is tempting to read it as a personal conviction. A study of S&P 500 bosses suggests something more calculated: Republican-donor CEOs were three times as likely as others to make social statements with a liberal slant, and the statements tended to pay off with customers and investors.

The paper, by Swarnodeep Homroy of the University of Groningen and Shubhashis Gangopadhyay of the India Development Foundation and UPES University, was published online in the Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis on December 5, 2023.

Statements that cut against the donors’ own politics

The authors gathered statements by S&P 500 CEOs from 2014 to 2019 on gender equality, racial diversity, immigration, gun control, the environment, universal healthcare and human rights. Comments about specific parties or politicians were left out. The final sample held 1,188 statements by the CEOs of 196 firms.

Using text analysis and Gallup polling on party positions, they found that 1,154 of the statements, or 97%, aligned with liberal Democratic views. The rest had no clear partisan lean, and none aligned with Republican positions. Yet Federal Election Commission records showed that 67% of the CEOs were Republican donors.

Activism was more likely when a firm operated in politically polarized states, when its employees leaned Democratic, when it sold to retail consumers and when it faced stiff competition. Shareholder proposals had no significant effect on whether CEOs spoke out.

Customers gained, few lost

To see how shoppers reacted, the authors used SafeGraph foot-traffic data for more than 190,000 stores of 208 firms, 81 of whose CEOs made a statement. Stores were classed by Donald Trump’s 2016 vote share in their county.

Store visits rose 3% in the month after a statement, compared with similar stores of firms that stayed quiet. The gain came from Democratic counties. In a narrower eight-week window, visits jumped 19.7% in strongly Democratic counties, where Trump won less than 20% of the vote, and 10.5% in moderately Democratic ones. Strongly Republican counties saw a 3.9% dip and moderately Republican ones 1.2%, and those visits had almost fully recovered within eight weeks.

The authors argue that because CEOs are widely assumed to be Republicans, a liberal statement carries new information and the risk of losing conservative customers makes it more credible.

A small bump for shareholders

Investors reacted positively on average, with a cumulative abnormal return of 0.12% over the three days around a statement, higher for firms in polarized markets and for Democrat-leaning statements. Sales rose for the first two quarters after a statement before fading, and firms were less likely to face shareholder activism on ESG issues.

The gains were strongest the first time a CEO spoke on an issue, and a good market reaction made further statements more likely. Being the first in an industry to respond to an event also paid more.

The authors note limits: statements are sporadic, so they focused on short-run effects, and they found no significant effect on long-term profitability, employee productivity or retention. What they did find is that a CEO’s public stance on a social issue was a poor guide to the CEO’s own politics.

Study Details:

  • Title: Strategic CEO Activism in Polarized Markets
  • Authors: Swarnodeep Homroy, Shubhashis Gangopadhyay
  • Journal: Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis
  • Publication Date: December 5, 2023
  • DOI: 10.1017/S0022109023001382