Charter schools run by Democrats and Republicans promise different things in their missions

Comparing the party makeup of charter school boards with the words in their mission and vision statements, researchers found that schools led by Democrats and by Republicans emphasize different values, suggesting charters cater to political as well as educational preferences.

Share this:

Charter schools are often sold as a way for families to pick an education that matches their philosophy. A new study suggests they may also be matching families’ politics. Schools governed by Democrats and schools governed by Republicans, it finds, describe their purpose in measurably different terms.

The paper, “Partisan Schools: The Political Alignment of Charter School Leadership”, is by Jason Giersch and Christopher Dong. It was published online in American Politics Research on August 9, 2025.

Board members and mission statements

The authors looked at the people who run charter schools and at what those schools say they stand for. They measured the partisan composition of charter school boards and tested whether it correlated with the word concepts that appeared in each school’s mission and vision statements.

Those statements are the public pitch a charter school makes to families, setting out its values and goals.

Different values on paper

The correlations showed that, in the authors’ words, “schools run by Democrats and schools run by Republicans value different things.” The balance of party affiliation on a board was linked to which ideas the school chose to emphasize.

The authors connect this to a long-standing promise of the school choice movement: that it would produce schools serving the particular interests of families with specific educational philosophies.

Their argument is that charter schools deliver on that promise in an additional, less advertised way. Beyond offering experiences tailored to educational preferences, they argue, charters offer experiences tailored to political preferences as well.

That puts a partisan dimension on what parents are choosing when they pick a charter school, through the leadership that sets its direction.

Study Details:

  • Title: Partisan Schools: The Political Alignment of Charter School Leadership
  • Authors: Jason Giersch, Christopher Dong
  • Journal: American Politics Research, Vol. 54, No. 1, pp. 120-134
  • Publication Date: August 9, 2025
  • DOI: 10.1177/1532673X251367386