Genes explain up to 49% of whether people see the world as safe and good

In about 9,000 Swedish twins, heritability of basic beliefs about the world ranged from 21% to 49%, while the shared family environment had negligible influence. The beliefs overlapped only modestly with personality.

Share this:

Whether you see the world as a safe, good and interesting place is partly in your genes. A study of about 9,000 Swedish twins found that genetic factors explain between 21% and 49% of the differences in people’s basic beliefs about the world, while the family home they grew up in left almost no trace.

The study was led by Sophie Perizonius with Laura W. Wesseldijk, Jeremy D.W. Clifton, Fredrik Ullén and Miriam A. Mosing, from the Karolinska Institute, the Max Planck Institute for Empirical Aesthetics, the University of Pennsylvania and other institutions. It was published online in The Journal of Positive Psychology on August 9, 2024. The authors call it the first twin study of these beliefs.

What primal world beliefs are

Psychologists call these beliefs “primals”. They are broad impressions of the world as a whole: whether it is safe, enticing, alive, and above all good. Earlier work by Clifton and colleagues linked more positive primals with higher well-being and less depression, anxiety and stress, and found the beliefs to be stable over time.

The team translated a short version of the Primals Inventory into Swedish, adding 11 more detailed beliefs, for 62 items in all. Participants rated each statement on a six-point scale and also completed a standard Big Five personality test.

How the twin comparison works

The data came from the Swedish Twin Registry. The final sample held 4,651 single twins and 2,419 complete pairs, aged 36 to 63, with an average age of about 50. Identical twins share essentially all their genes, while fraternal twins share on average half. If identical twins resemble each other more on a trait, genes are likely playing a role. The analysis was preregistered.

Broad-sense heritability ranged from 21% for the belief that the world is “Abundant” to 49% for the belief that it is “Intentional”, the latter about as heritable as personality traits, which typically sit around 40%. The rest of the variation came from experiences unique to each person, plus measurement error. Shared environmental effects, such as parenting and the neighbourhood twins grew up in, were negligible for every belief measured.

Related to personality, but not the same thing

Primals and personality overlapped only modestly. Agreeableness had the strongest link with the belief that the world is good (r = .35), Extraversion was next (r = .32), and Neuroticism was most strongly tied to seeing the world as unsafe (r = -.33). Openness correlated most with seeing the world as enticing (r = .22). The authors conclude that primals and personality are “related, yet distinct, constructs.”

They also note limits. Internal reliability was low for several scales, which may have inflated the share attributed to individual experience. Only 11 of 22 detailed beliefs were measured, and the sample was a single middle-aged Swedish birth cohort. The authors stress that heritable does not mean fixed: people may have a predisposition, but which interventions can shift these beliefs has yet to be tested.

Study Details:

  • Title: The world as I see it: genetic and environmental influences on primal world beliefs in a large Swedish twin sample
  • Authors: Sophie Perizonius, Laura W. Wesseldijk, Jeremy D.W. Clifton, Fredrik Ullén, Miriam A. Mosing
  • Journal: The Journal of Positive Psychology
  • Publication Date: August 9, 2024
  • DOI: 10.1080/17439760.2024.2387340