Donald Trump cast himself as the disruptor and Joe Biden as the restorer of tradition. But when three political scientists compared the language in their formal speeches, the two men turned out to sound surprisingly similar.
The research note is by Rebecca Eissler of San Francisco State University, Annelise Russell of the University of Kentucky and Sean Theriault of the University of Texas at Austin. It was published online in American Politics Research on August 27, 2024.
Seven pairs of speeches
The researchers ran the speeches through LIWC, a widely used language analysis program that sorts words into categories. They focused on five dimensions linked to presidential leadership: clout, authenticity, power, positive emotion and negative emotion. Their prediction was that Trump would score higher on clout, power and negativity, and Biden higher on authenticity and positive emotion.
First they held time constant, using five pairs from the 2020 campaign: early stump speeches, convention acceptance speeches, the first debate, the dueling town halls of October 15 and closing speeches in Tampa on October 29.
Only 7 of the 25 comparisons showed a statistically significant difference, and only two of those went the way the authors expected. Trump showed more clout in his acceptance speech and in the debate. But Biden showed more clout at the town halls, and Trump was more positive twice. The candidates never differed on power language.
The pair were most different in the first debate, where the opponent was literally in the room, and most similar in their closing speeches. The authors suggest that roles mattered: as the incumbent seeking another term, Trump needed a more positive message than the challenger.
Formal speeches, different years
Next they held the setting constant and let time vary, comparing Trump’s 2017 inaugural address and first joint address to Congress with Biden’s in 2021. Here half the differences were significant. Trump used more clout in both. Biden showed more authenticity in his address to Congress.
Biden was also more negative in his inaugural address, which the authors tie to the moment: the Covid-19 vaccine rollout was only starting and the attack on the Capitol had just happened.
The office shapes the voice
The authors argue that the presidency is constraining enough that “even the most unorthodox candidate’s rhetoric mirrors that of a traditionalist.” The sharp differences visible on Twitter and cable news largely disappear in traditional settings.
They acknowledge they may have chosen the wrong dimensions or speeches, but note that they picked the cases where differences should have been easiest to find. A further check on how often each man invoked the past, present and future pointed the same way.
Study Details:
- Title: Research Note: “Comparing Traditional Presidential Rhetoric: Trump Versus Biden”
- Authors: Rebecca Eissler, Annelise Russell, Sean Theriault
- Journal: American Politics Research
- Publication Date: August 27, 2024
- DOI: 10.1177/1532673X241276413
