Men still dominate conference Q&A sessions online, taking up to 80% of question time

Across four virtual academic conferences, men took a larger share of question time than their numbers justified, up to 80% at one meeting, and the gap was no smaller than at the same conference held in person.

Share this:

Moving academic conferences online did not give women a bigger share of the microphone. Across four virtual meetings, men asked more than their share of questions and took up more than their share of question time, and the gap looked the same as it did in person.

The study was led by Shoshana N. Jarvis of the Haas School of Business at the University of California, Berkeley, with colleagues from Berkeley, Columbia Business School and the American Institutes for Research. It was published online in Sex Roles on November 6, 2023.

Many people hoped virtual formats would level the field. Chat boxes, asynchronous threads and the absence of a queue at a floor microphone were supposed to lower the social cost of speaking up. The researchers tested that hope directly.

Four conferences, one stubborn pattern

The team watched recorded Q&A sessions, timed every question and compared each gender’s share of participation with its share of attendees.

At the first, a small Zoom conference with 243 attendees, men were 42% of the audience but took 62% of the total Q&A time. At the second, a conference of 172 attendees held on Zoom, men occupied 80% of the question time. That same conference had been held in person the year before, and men’s outsized share did not differ significantly between the two years.

The third meeting was meant to be the best case for women. It had 3,888 attendees, 65% of them women, and all questions were typed into a text thread. Men were 31% of attendees, yet they started 39% of the Q&A exchanges and wrote 40% of all question text, both significantly more than their numbers predicted.

Graduate students drove the chat gap

In that all-text conference, academic rank mattered. Among graduate students, men wrote an average of 330 words per Q&A exchange against 260 for women. At higher ranks the difference faded, and the raw averages for most senior groups actually leaned slightly toward women.

The fourth conference, the main annual meeting of a large field with more than 10,000 attendees, let the team compare formats within one event across 601 Q&A exchanges. Women sent 53% of chat questions but only 44% of questions asked on video. Men wrote longer chat questions, 239 words on average against 195 for women. Men also asked longer spoken questions when all questions were saved for the end of a session, while women’s question length did not change.

Beyond that, no format choice, whether chat only, video only, or questions between talks, reliably changed which gender asked. What did matter was the topic area: in some subfield divisions women were far more likely to ask, and in one they were less likely.

Limits the authors flag

Several samples were small, and some individual comparisons did not reach statistical significance, although they pointed the same way. Gender was coded from pronouns, photos and names, which can misclassify people. At the largest conference, a scraper fault captured only part of the attendee list, so the team could not compare participation with the real gender mix.

The authors write that the gaps showed a “durability” across “modalities and formats”, pointing to norms and backlash fears rather than room layout. For organisers, the practical takeaway is that a chat box alone will not fix who gets heard; the culture of a subfield may matter more.

Study Details:

  • Title: Do Virtual Environments Close the Gender Gap in Participation in Question-and-Answer Sessions at Academic Conferences? In Search of Moderation by Conference Format
  • Authors: Shoshana N. Jarvis, Christine Q. Nguyen, Minwan Zhu, Charles R. Ebersole, Laura J. Kray
  • Journal: Sex Roles
  • Publication Date: November 6, 2023
  • DOI: 10.1007/s11199-023-01388-4