Skipping through videos to escape boredom tends to make people more bored

Across seven experiments with 1,223 people, students who could skip between or within videos felt more bored and less satisfied than when they watched one video through, although the effect was weaker in older, more varied adult samples.

Share this:

Skipping from video to video when you are bored feels like the obvious cure. A set of seven experiments suggests it often does the opposite: people who were free to switch and fast-forward ended up more bored than people who simply watched one video through.

The research comes from Katy Y. Y. Tam and Michael Inzlicht of the University of Toronto Scarborough, with Inzlicht also at the Rotman School of Management. It appeared in the October 2024 issue of the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General under the title “Fast-Forward to Boredom: How Switching Behavior on Digital Media Makes People More Bored”. The experiments involved 1,223 participants in total, and six of the seven were preregistered.

Bored people switch, and expect switching to help

The authors call the habit “digital switching”: jumping between videos or skipping forward and back inside one. In the first study, students watched a set of videos pretested as either boring or interesting for 10 minutes each. In the boring set, the median participant skipped to the next video eight times, against four times in the interesting set, and they also scrubbed back and forth within videos more often.

A second study asked students to imagine 10 minutes with either a locked video or videos they could skip. They predicted that switching would make them less bored, more satisfied and more engaged, and 81% said they would rather have the option to switch.

The prediction turned out to be wrong for students

Studies 3 and 4 tested that belief directly. In Study 3, each student spent 10 minutes on one locked 10-minute documentary-style video and, separately, 10 minutes with seven 5-minute videos they could skip at will. Boredom was lower in the no-switching condition (3.26 versus 3.72 on a 7-point scale), and the single video was also rated as more satisfying, more engaging and more meaningful.

Study 4 gave participants a 50-minute video they could fast-forward through for 10 minutes, compared with a 10-minute video they could not skip. Again, the locked video left people less bored (3.02 versus 3.47) and scored higher on satisfaction, attention and meaning.

Study 5 moved the test onto YouTube itself. Participants either picked one video of their choice and watched it without skipping, or used YouTube however they normally would. The no-switching condition was slightly less boring, a small effect, with no difference in satisfaction, attention or meaning. When asked why they had switched, 70% of respondents gave reasons related to boredom, even though they had not been told the study was about boredom.

Older, more varied samples muddied the picture

The effect did not hold everywhere. Study 6 repeated the design with short online articles instead of videos, using 178 U.S. adults recruited through Prolific with an average age of about 40. Study 7 returned to videos with 175 U.S. adults recruited through CloudResearch, average age 36. In both, a straight comparison found no overall difference in boredom between switching and not switching.

The order of the two conditions mattered, though. People who started with the single item were less bored with it than with the switching condition. People who started by switching felt more bored when they then had to stick with one item. In Study 7, the researchers also found that switching raised perceived opportunity cost, the nagging sense that something better is available elsewhere.

The authors note that the student samples in Studies 1 to 5 averaged 19 years old and are likely more practised with digital media than the broader adult samples. They also stress they are not claiming that every way of escaping boredom backfires, only that this particular habit can. In their words, enjoyment “likely comes from immersing oneself in the videos rather than swiping through them.”

In the student experiments, the size of the boredom gap was small to moderate, but it ran consistently against what participants themselves had predicted they would feel.

Study Details:

  • Title: Fast-Forward to Boredom: How Switching Behavior on Digital Media Makes People More Bored
  • Authors: Katy Y. Y. Tam, Michael Inzlicht
  • Journal: Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, Vol. 153, No. 10
  • Publication Date: October 2024
  • DOI: 10.1037/xge0001639