The colleagues who read your drafts may matter more to your academic career than the ones who put their names on your papers. A study of two decades of political science publishing finds that informal feedback ties, traced through the thank-you notes in articles, are a stronger predictor of a scholar’s impact than coauthorship.
The research, by Lluís Danús, William Dinneen, Carolina Torreblanca, Guy Grossman and Sandra González-Bailón of the University of Pennsylvania and Stanford Law School, was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences on April 27, 2026.
Reading the thank-you notes
Informal help such as mentoring and feedback rarely leaves a record. The authors found one in acknowledgment sections, where researchers thank people who commented on their work.
They collected 129,750 articles published in 174 political science journals from 2003 to 2023, written by 85,653 scholars, and built two networks: one of coauthors and one of people thanked. Political science uses double-blind review and bars acknowledgments during review, which makes strategic thank-yous less likely.
A bigger network, and a bigger payoff
The acknowledgment network was larger and less fragmented, with 124,023 people and an average of 5.81 connections each, compared with 2.85 in the coauthorship network. About 19% of scholars had no formal or informal connections at all.
Disconnected scholars had lower impact at almost every level of productivity. In the lowest decile, the mean h-index of scholars connected in the acknowledgment network was more than twice that of isolated ones, and their Euclid score was seven times higher.
Using matching on gender, seniority, methods, location and institutional prestige, plus random forest models, the team found that being connected in the acknowledgment network was the single most important correlate of publication impact. Having coauthors came second.
The benefits are unevenly spread. Women had similar centrality to men among coauthors once their smaller numbers in the field were accounted for, but men were more central in the acknowledgment network.
Associations, not proof of cause
The authors caution that acknowledgments capture only part of the informal exchanges that happen, so their network is a partial and noisy picture. Scholars who are disconnected may also differ in unobserved ways that affect their impact.
They describe their estimates as robust associations rather than causal pathways. Still, the pattern is clear in the data: in a field where 57.56% of articles have a single author, the people thanked at the end of a paper trace a support structure that coauthorship alone misses.
Study Details:
- Title: Informal connections outweigh coauthorship ties in academic impact
- Authors: Lluís Danús, William Dinneen, Carolina Torreblanca, Guy Grossman, Sandra González-Bailón
- Journal: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Publication Date: April 27, 2026
- DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2511050123
